Source: PURDUE UNIVERSITY submitted to
MULTICULTURAL PERSPECTIVES ON SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE: LESSONS FROM COSTA RICA
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0218369
Grant No.
2009-51160-05466
Project No.
INDE-2009-00953
Proposal No.
2009-00953
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
AA-N
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2009
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2013
Grant Year
2009
Project Director
Gibson, K. D.
Recipient Organization
PURDUE UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
WEST LAFAYETTE,IN 47907
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
This is a three-year, joint effort between Purdue University and Haskell Indian Nations University to develop a program that addresses sustainable agriculture in the tropics. Sixteen undergraduates, eight from each institution, will attend a new two-credit course in spring semesters. The course will review sustainable agriculture concepts, major cropping systems in the tropics, and the impact of trade on U.S. and Central American growers. The course will be offered to both institutions through distance learning technology. Native American attitudes and philosophy toward agriculture and sustainability will be a major topic in the course. The students also will attend a fifteen day course in Costa Rica during which they will visit natural and agricultural systems including coffee, cacao, banana, and vegetable productions. Students will interact directly with growers and consumers to learn about Costa Rican perceptions of sustainable agriculture. The short course will include a service learning project in which students assist members of ACOMUITA, an indigenous women's group who are developing an agroforestry business. Four students, two from each university, will remain in Costa Rica for an eight week summer research experience. The project will increase capacity for Haskell and Purdue to conduct collaborative research in Latin America, and enhance international curricula to ensure that Purdue and Haskell students gain an understanding of issues related to international agricultural production systems and trade. Additionally, this project will engage Native American undergraduates early in their collegiate education and help to put them on the path toward graduate degrees in agriculture and natural resources.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
90360993020100%
Goals / Objectives
Our primary goal is to enhance the international science curricula offered at Haskell and Purdue by developing a program that integrates coursework, study abroad, and undergraduate research in Costa Rica to teach students about sustainable agriculture. Specifically, we will develop and offer students at Purdue and Haskell a two-credit course on sustainable agriculture in the tropics, add a service learning component to the existing study abroad course, and formalize and partially fund summer research opportunities with CATIE for Purdue and Haskell students. The proposed courses will address indigenous approaches to agriculture and include significant numbers of Native American students. We have two secondary goals. First, we will build collaborative relationships between Haskell and Purdue faculty and students that will encourage Haskell students to pursue graduate education in agriculture and natural resources. Second, we will increase the interest of participating students in international experiences, including semester abroad programs, and in learning about other cultures. Expected outcomes include: 1) a two credit spring semester course entitled "Sustainable Agriculture in the Tropics", 2) a short course focused on agriculture and indigenous knowledge in Costa Rica, 3) a minimum of sixteen students per year - eight from each institute - will take the courses, and 4) four students will participate in an eight week summer research program in Costa Rica each year
Project Methods
We will develop a two-credit course entitled "Sustainable Agriculture in the Tropics". In spring 2009, students will attend lectures and discussions on sustainable agriculture, including indigenous and western approaches to nature and agriculture, international trade and economics, cropping systems and major ecosystems in the tropics. The course will be offered annually to students at both institutions through distance education, web-based course organization, and on-line meeting tools. The PIs will serve as the primary instructors with supplemental guest lectures on economics and current production systems from PU faculty and on globalization and indigenous land use practices from Haskell faculty and other guest speakers. After completing the spring course, faculty and sixteen students will travel to Costa Rica for a two-week, three credit course. Students will participate in four primary learning activities: field sampling, completion of written assignments, direct interaction with farmers, and group discussions. Relevant topics will be discussed by faculty and students during evening meetings. The course itinerary is designed around the discussion topics and relevant agricultural systems will be visited to insure that students received sufficient background to address the topics. Students will spend four days working with indigenous tribes near the Caribbean coast that have developed small businesses to sell cacao and other agroforestry goods. Students will assist the indigenous workers and learn components of this business, including crop biology, pest management, harvesting, processing, and sales. We will contrast this production system and view of sustainability with larger and more profitable businesses such as pineapple and coffee. Students will directly address the role of culture in shaping perspectives on sustainability. This component of the course will build upon discussions of indigenous knowledge and perspectives and increase the relevance of the course for Native students. We will also use ISE funds to partially support eight week long summer research projects in Costa Rica. The research projects will start at the conclusion of the study abroad course, allowing students to remain in Costa Rica after the course. Students will join existing projects being conducted in Costa Rica by CATIE or Purdue faculty. Potential topics include coffee production, pest management, agroforestry, and effects of agriculture on tropical diversity. Students will prepare a short written report on their experience and present the report to their mentors. Outcome measures used to evaluate impact will include: 1)number of students who participate in courses and summer research, 2) mastery of course content assessed through exams, assigned paper and oral presentations, and journal entries, 3) strengths and weaknesses of the project assessed with questionnaires and informally through one-on-one and group meetings, 4) pre and post questionnaires and exit interviews used to assess changes in student behavior and attitudes, and 5) number of students who participate in additional international activities

Progress 09/01/09 to 08/31/13

Outputs
Target Audience: Target audiences included undergraduate students at Haskell Indian Nations University and at Purdue University as well as faculty at both institutions. The target audience also included university educators interested in developing student abroad courses for multicultural audiences. Changes/Problems: In addition to the semester and study abroad courses, we proposed an 8 week summer research program in Costa Rica. However, student interest was relatively low and program logistics were challenging. We supported three students but discontinued the research program after two summers. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Students increased their knowledge of natural and agricultural ecosystems, gained experience working in multicultural groups, and became familiar with Costa Rican culture and history. Faculty gained experience organizing and leading study abroad courses, delivering content through distance technologies, and in working with a multicultural student body. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Results were conveyed to the general publicthrough a peer-reviewed publication. Students at Haskell Indian Nations University presented their experiences to their classmates after their return through posters and in-class discussion. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? A three credit hour course, "Multicultural Perspectives in Sustainable Agriculture", was taught in spring semester from 2010 to 2013 to students at Haskell Indian Nations University and Purdue University. The course met twice each week (each lecture was 75 minutes) using Adobe Connect, a web-based communication platform. Five main topics were covered during each semester: (1) perspectives on the sustainability of U.S. agriculture, (2) an indigenous perspective on land use and agriculture, (3) biodiversity and tropical ecosystems, (4) Costa Rica history and culture, and (5) tropical crops. In addition to the synchronously taught classroom, students participated in two key activities: reciprocal campus visits and a project in which each student interviewed two to three adults about their perspectives on the sustainability of U.S. agriculture. Both activities were intended to increase student exposure to different backgrounds and cultures. The semester course was followed by a three-credit, two-week course in Costa Rica entitled "Biodiversity in Natural and Agricultural Systems". Students visited conventional and organic agricultural systems and participated in service learning projects at three indigenous villages. Forty-six students (25 from HINU, 21 from PU) took the semester course from 2010 to 2012; annual enrollment ranged between 11 and 16 students. Most students at both institutions were in their junior or senior year when they took the course and most were enrolled in a science major. Less than half of the students at both institutions were from rural communities and less than a third of the HINU students were from reservation communities. However, several HINU students indicated on their forms that they grew up in some combination of reservation and rural or urban/suburban communities. More female students than male students enrolled in the course at both universities. Quantitative and qualitative data were used to determine student engagement and program assessment. Students at both universities posted comments and questions frequently during the lectures and were generally satisfied with the technology used to deliver the lectures. As measured by the number of comments and questions posted during the lectures, Native American males were particularly engaged by course content. The interest of Native American males in working in multicultural groups also increased significantly during the semester although no differences were detected for Purdue males or for women at either institution. Students emphasized the importance of the reciprocal visits and projects for getting to know each other outside the classroom in both written and verbal comments. An online questionnaire with both Likert-style and open-ended questions was administered in 2013 to assess student perceptions of the course at least one year after completing the course. Twenty-five students completed the questionnaire and reported increased knowledge of relevant topics and personal growth. Despite differences in ethnicity and culture, the HINU and PU students did not differ in their positive assessment of the course. Our experience suggests that study abroad programs can be developed and offered through partnerships between TCUs and PWIs that provide substantial benefits to students at both institutions.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2014 Citation: Gibson, K.D., T. J. Benjamin, B.R. K. Chapin, C.Y. Oseto, and A. M. Lucietto. 2014. Engaging undergraduate students from two institutions in a multicultural synchronously taught agriculture course. North American Colleges Teachers of Agriculture (NACTA) 58:32-38.


Progress 09/01/11 to 08/31/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: A three credit hour course, "Multicultural Perspectives in Sustainable Agriculture", was taught to thirteen students during spring semester 2012 to students at Haskell Indian Nations University and Purdue University. Course materials (syllabus, lectures, assignments) were revised based on our experience teaching in 2011 but core features of the course (real-time lectures with AdobeConnect, online discussions, presentations by the students about their backgrounds and thei perspectives on sustainable land management, etc). The Purdue students visited Haskell Indian Nations Univeristy for three days. They interacted with Haskell students and faculty, toured the campus, and learned about the history of the university. Unfortunately, Haskell students were not able to visit Purdue in 2012. The semester course was followed by a three-credit, two-week course in Costa Rica entitled "Biodiversity in Natural and Agricultural Systems". Students visited conventional and organic agricultural systems and participated in service learning projects at three indigenous villages. Data developed from the semester course were analyzed and a manuscript developed that will be submitted to a peer-reviewed publication. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: The target audiences for this project included students and faculty at both institutions. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The courses had a similar impact on students in 2012 as in 2010 and 2011. Students gained experience working in culturally diverse groups and their interest in agricultural careers, including graduate school, increased. Student understanding of sustainable agriculture and indigenous philosophies of land use increased as measured by exams, term papers, and journal entries. Interest of non-majors in agriculture increased as measured by pre and post questionnaires. Interest in study abroad and international agriculture was also increased. Faculty gained experience working with culturally diverse students and in using distance learning tools such as AdobeConnect and VoiceThread. Based on the number of comments posted during lectures and on pre and post questionnaires, male students from Haskell Indian Nations University were particularly engaged in the lectures and evidenced the greatest interest at the end of the course in working in multicultural groups. Two new courses that will be available to students at both institutions through distance learning are being developed.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 09/01/10 to 08/31/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: A three credit hour course, "Multicultural Perspectives in Sustainable Agriculture", was taught to thirteen students during spring semester 2011 to students at Haskell Indian Nations University and Purdue University. Course materials (syllabus, lectures, assignments) were revised based on our experience teaching in 2010. A commercially available software program, VoiceThread, was used to encourage interaction and facilitate discussion online among students. VoiceThread, allows students to post written, audio, and video comments in response to class assignments. Students traveled from their home institutions to the partner institution for three to four days to interact in person with each other and to learn about the partner institution. Students presented audio and video interviews of their family and friends about during the visit. The interviews focused on perceptions of sustainability and included information about the presenting student's background. During their visit to Purdue University, students from Haskell Indian Nations University also participated in a plant ecology course field project. The semester course was followed by a three-credit, two-week course in Costa Rica entitled "Biodiversity in Natural and Agricultural Systems". Students visited conventional and organic agricultural systems and participated in service learning projects at three indigenous villages. One student returned to two of the indigenous villages for a summer internship. The courses were featured in Purdue University's Agricultures magazine. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Target audiences included undergraduate students at Haskell Indian Nations University and at Purdue University as well as faculty at both institutions. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The courses had a similar impact on students in 2011 as in 2010. Students gained experience working in culturally diverse groups and their interest in agricultural careers, including graduate school, increased. Student understanding of sustainable agriculture and indigenous philosophies of land use increased as measured by exams, term papers, and journal entries. Interest of non-majors in agriculture increased as measured by pre and post questionnaires. Interest in study abroad and international agriculture was also increased. Faculty gained experience working with culturally diverse students and in using distance learning tools such as AdobeConnect and VoiceThread. Haskell Indian Nations University who attended the 2010 course started a Ph.D program in the College of Agriculture at Purdue University.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 09/01/09 to 08/31/10

Outputs
A new three credit hour courses was developed and taught. "Multicultural Perspectives in Sustainable Agriculture" was taught to 21 students during spring semester 2010. The course was taught simultaneously to students at Haskell Indian Nations University and Purdue University using AdobeConnect and online collaboration tools like Google documents and Facebook. Students traveled from their home institution to the partner institution for three to four days during the course. An existing course "Biodiversity in Natural and Agricultural Systems" was revised to follow the semester course. Sixteen students from Purdue and Haskell Indian Nations participated in a Maymester course on sustainable agriculture in Costa Rica from May 24 to June 8, 2010. Students visited several agricultural systems including coffee, banana, and cacao. They participated in service learning projects at three indigenous villages within Costa Rica. Two students remained in Costa Rica after the course for an eight week internship. We hoped to support four students but funds for two internships were used instead to reduce the costs of the Maymester course enough to attract students. PRODUCTS: Course syllabi, lectures, and supporting educational material were developed. A course website was developed in fall 2009 and launched before the semester course started. Internship projects were developed and interns selected. An itinerary for the Maymester course was developed and travel arrangements made. New service learning activities were developed for the Maymester course. OUTCOMES: Student understanding of sustainable agriculture and indigenous philosophies of land use increased as measured by exams, term papers, and journal entries. Interest of non-majors in agriculture increased as measured by pre and post questionnaires. Interest in study abroad and international agriculture was also increased. Faculty and students gained experience using distance learning tools such as AdobeConnect. DISSEMINATION ACTIVITIES: The courses were advertised at each campus through directed email, fliers, and call-out meetings. FUTURE INITIATIVES: We will use feedback from students to refine the semester and Maymester course. Both courses will be offered in 2011. We will repeat pre and post questionnaires and develop an article on teaching sustainable agriculture for submission to a peer-reviewed journal. We anticipate reallocating funds from the internships to reduce course costs to minimize financial obstacles to participation.

Impacts
Students gained experience working in culturally diverse groups and have maintained contact after the course ended. Interest in and knowledge of agricultural careers has increased at Haskell Indian Nations. We anticipate that at least one Haskell student from the course will apply to graduate school at Purdue in the College of Agriculture.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period