Progress 03/01/15 to 08/31/17
Outputs Target Audience:Similar to the previous report, and the overall motivation of the project, the target audience of the project includes staff and managers for water districts and wastewater treatment plants, as well as the academic community that engages in research on water scarcity, water reliability, water recycling, water reuse, wastewater recyclingand water conservation. In addition, our reserach targets those sectors that are concerned with opportunities to meet their water demand in and near municipal centers at low cost, including agricultural operators, and agencies interested in groundwater recharge. Efforts over this reporting period and the project in general include presentations at an academic conference to reach other scientists, to city operators and wastewater treatment plant staff, and one published technical journal article that has reached professionals, agencies, and academics. Changes/Problems:
Nothing Reported
What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?It provided training and funding support to two graduate students at the University of California Riverside. First, the research has lead to two publications (and two out o the three required papers) for Q. Tran's dissertation (she will be receiving her PhD in Chemical and Environmental Engineering at UC Riverside.. This project also is the basis for her three research project. The project has also supported research by R. Amin and our efforts to illustrate how drought and water conservation activities throughout California have affected influent and effluent flow and quality. R. Amin is a masters student in Public Policy at UC Riverside. This research also lead to her receiving a summer internship at the Water Policy Center of the Public Policy Institute of California during the summer of 2017 to do research on this issue. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The results have been disseminated to the communities of interest through a variety of venues. For, for the academic community, we have have published papers in high quality peer-reviewed research journals. For water agency managers and stakeholders, in addition to our research publications, we have given numerous presentations at regional, state, and national conferences. We have also met one-on-one with waterwater and water agency managers to discuss our findings. For both water agency managers and the public, our findings have been disseminated in various media outlets (including Science Daily, the Water Education Foundation, and the Inland Empire Press Enterprise). Finally, we are working on a short policy brief and blog to be posted by the Water Policy Center of the Public Policy Institute of California. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?
Nothing Reported
Impacts What was accomplished under these goals?
The long-terms goals we accomplished included: (a) illustrating how treated municipal wastewater (TMW) can be produced at a much lower cost than currently and in a manner that is better suited to meet demand characteristics, (b) how drought and water conservation efforts may work to reduce the availability and quality of TMW, (c) how WWTP operators can respond in a cost-effective manner to address the quality impications of drought and/or water conservation efforts on the quality of TMW, (d) how WWTP processes can be optimized to deliver a more cost-effective product--both TMW and ADW to agricultural operators, and (e) how reuse of TMW and ADW within a regional water supply setting can improve society welfare. In particular, three specific outcomes include: 1. Using a cost-minimization framework, we identify least-cost solutions consisting of treatment processes and their intensities (blending ratios) to produce alternative irrigation sources for citrus and turfgrass. Our analysis illustrates the benefits of employing an optimization framework and flexible treatment design to identify cost-effective blending opportunities that may produce high-quality irrigation water for a wide range of end uses. 2. We illustrated, using a case study from Southern California during its most recent drought, how drought and water conservation strategies combine to reduce influent flow and quality and, subsequently, effluent flow and quality. Second, we use a recently developed regional water reuse decision support model (RWRM) to highlight cost-effective strategies that can be implemented to mitigate the impacts of drought on effluent water quality. While the solutions we identify cannot increase the flow of influent or effluent coming into or out of a treatment plant, they can improve the value of the remaining effluent in a cost-effective manner that takes into account the characteristics of its demand, whether it be for landscaping, golf courses, agricultural irrigation, or surface water augmentation. 3. We found that from a regional perspective, and in the case of Israel with the use of the MYWAS model, that: (1) enabling agricultural irrigation with treated wastewater significantly reduces the optimal capacity levels of seawater and brackish-water desalination over the simulated 3-decade period, and increases Israel'swelfare by 3.3 billion USD in terms of present values; (2) a policy requiring desalination of treatedwastewater pre-agricultural reuse, as a method to prevent long-run damage to the soil and groundwater, reduceswelfare by 2.7 billion USD; hence, such a policy is warranted only if the avoided damages exceed this welfare loss; (3) desalination of treated wastewater in order to increase freshwater availability for agricultural irrigation is not optimal, since the costs overwhelm the generated agricultural benefits. We also find the results associated with these three topics to be sensitive to the natural recharge of Israel's freshwater aquifers, and to the rate at which domestic-water demand evolves due to population and income growth.
Publications
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2017
Citation:
Tran, Q., Jassby, D. and Schwabe, K.A. 2017. The Implications of Drought and Water Conservation on the Reuse of Municipal Wastewater: Recognizing Impacts and Identifying Mitigation Possibilities. Water Research 124, 472-481
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2017
Citation:
Reznik, A., Feinerman, I., Finkelshtain, I., Fisher, F., Huber-Lee, A., Joyce, B., and I. Kan. 2017. Economic implications of agricultural reuse of treated wastewater in Israel: A statewide long-term perspective. Ecological Economics 135:222-233.
- Type:
Conference Papers and Presentations
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
(Presentation given by Q. Tran) Wastewater Reuse for Agriculture: Development of a Regional Water Reuse Decision-support model for Cost-effective Irrigation.(w/ D. Jassby) Presented at WaterSmart Innovation Conference and Exposition. Las Vegas, NV., October 5-7, 2016
- Type:
Conference Papers and Presentations
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
(Presentation given by K. Schwabe).Sustainable Water Resources in Urban Environments: Challenges and Opportunities." Presented at Drought Vulnerability and Tools for Improving Water Resilience. National Water Resource Institute. Long Beach, CA. October 20th, 2016.
- Type:
Conference Papers and Presentations
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2017
Citation:
(Presentation given by B. Chefetz). Human exposure to wastewater derived pharmaceuticals in fresh produce: Current knowledge and challenges. Presented at the University of California Riverside Environmental Science Seminar Series. July, 2017. Riverside California.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
Fedorova, G., J. Ben Ari, G. Tadmor, O. Paltiel, B. Chefetz. 2016. Environmental exposure to pharmaceuticals: A new technique for trace analysis of carbamazepine and its metabolites in human urine. Environmental Pollution 213:308-313.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
Paltiel, O., G. Fedorova, G. Tadmor, G. Kleinstern, Y. Maor, B. Chefetz. 2016. Human exposure to wastewater-derived pharmaceuticals in fresh produce: A randomized controlled trial focusing on carbamazepine. Environmental Science and Technology 50:4476-4482.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
Paz A., G. Tadmor, T. Malchi, J. Blotevogel, T. Borch, T. Polubesova, B. Chefetz. 2016. Fate of carbamazepine, its metabolites, and lamotrigine in soils irrigated with reclaimed wastewater: Sorption, leaching and plant uptake. Chemosphere 160:22-29.
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Under Review
Year Published:
2017
Citation:
Ben Mordechay, E., J. Tarchitzky, Y. Chen, M. Shenker, and B. Chefetz. 2017. Composted Biosolids and Treated Wastewater as Sources of Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care Products for Plant Uptake: A Case Study with Carbamazepine. Environmental Pollution.
|
Progress 03/01/16 to 02/28/17
Outputs Target Audience:Similar to the previous report, and the overall motivation of the project, the target audience of the project includes staff and managers for water districts and wastewater treatment plants, as well as the academic community that engages in research on water scarcity, water reliability, water recycling, water reuse, wastewater recyclingand water conservation. In addition, our reserach targets those sectors that are concerned with opportunities to meet their water demand in and near municipal centers at low cost, including agricultural operators. Efforts over this reporting period include presentations at an academic conference to reach other scientists, to city operators and wastewater treatment plant staff, and one published technical journal article that has reached professionals, agencies, and academics. Changes/Problems:
Nothing Reported
What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project's main focus in this area has been on the training and professional development of two PhD students. In the US, Schwabe and Jassby are training a PhD student (Quyhn Tran) in Environmental and Chemical Engineering through one-on-one mentoring. In Israel, Kan and Chefetz are training Ami Reznik in Environmental Economics and Management. Each has played an integral role in developing the their respective models with Tran developing the RWRM model in the US and Reznik developing the first version of the RWRM. We have also started mentoring a master's student in public policy on this project. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?As indicated above (in the "Other Products" section), in addition to publishing an article in the journal, Science, Technologiy, and the Environment, we have given four presentations at local, regoinal, and national venues to other academics, agency staff, and stakeholders. We have also given met one-on-one with some wastewater treatment plant staff and city managers about how they may be able to use our model to help them address wastewater issues. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Publishing another manuscript that looks at how conservation actions by water districts influences the costs confronted by WWTPs to reclaim municipal wastewater and the subsequent effects on effluent quality. We then want to further investigate the implications of that changes in effluent quality on crop yields and grower profits, and on instream water quality. Finally, we want to investigate the costs and benefits of mitigating those impacts. Additionally, we wan to finalize the response functions to better represent the impacts of differences in effluent quality and irrigation quality on crop response. Recall that this is a two-year seed grant with the idea to better understand the central issues in the area reusing treated municipal wastewater in agricultural environments. We've made some significant progress in this area, especially with developing the model and illustrating its benefit to local and regional wastewater treatment managers and agricultural operators. Our next step is to scale this research up and make the model more flexible to be easily adapted elsewhere regoinally. Also, we've identified an issue that will require more significant attention -- the impacts of contaminants of emerging concern--as an area that we need to expand upon.
Impacts What was accomplished under these goals?
One of the accomplishments over this period was to finalize the development of the first generation regional water reuse decision-support model (RWRM) using the general algebraic modeling system and to use that model to analyze the cost-effectiveness of alternative treatment trains to generate irrigation water from reclaimed wastewater, with the irrigation water designed to meet crop requirements as well as California's wastewater reuse regulations (Title 22). Using a cost-minimization framework, least-cost solutions consisting of treatment processes and their intensities (blending ratios) were identified to produce alternative irrigation sources for citrus and turfgrass. Our analysis illustrated the benefits of employing an optimization framework and flexible treatment design to identify cost-effective blending opportunities that may produce high quality irrigation water for a wide range of end uses. A second accomplishment was to extend the model aboevl to evaluate the suitability of treated wastewater for crop irrigation during droughts by studying the Inland Empire Utilities Agency - Regional Water Recycling Plant #4 (IEUA - RP4). The impacts and implications of drought on wastewater quality and the ripple effects of deterioration in discharges from wastewater treatment plants on our watersheds were also investigated. Using the revised regional water reuse decision-support model (rRWRM), the least-costly solutions to the irrigation sources and the deterioration of wastewater effluents are identified to retrieve the pre-drought period water/wastewater quality and to produce suitable irrigation water for crops. One outcome of this research is to recommend strict monitoring and more stringent regulating of wastewater discharges to ensure wastewater effluent quality complies with the discharge limitations. We are in the process of finalizing a manuscript to be submitted for publication. A third accomplishment of this research is to begin the development and analysis of the implications of drought on influent and effluent quality and flow volumes. While we're in the initial stages of our analysis, this research will have substantial implications for our understanding of the impacts of state conservation mandates to conserve water on WWTP operations and the resulting impact on the availability and quality of treated municipal wastewater for irrirgated agricultue on urban-rural fringe.
Publications
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
Tran, Q., Schwabe, K., Jassby, D. 2016. Wastewater Reuse for Agriculture: Development of a Regional Water Reuse Decision-Support Model (RWRM) for Cost-Effective Irrigation Sources. Environmental Science and Technology, DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.6b02073, 2016
|
Progress 03/01/15 to 02/29/16
Outputs Target Audience: The target audience for this first half of the project includes staff and managers for water districts and wastewater treatment plants, as well as the academic community that engages in research on water scarcity, water reliability, water recycling, water reuse, wastewater recyclingand water conservation. In addition, our reserach targets those sectors that are concerned with opportunities to meet their water demand in and near municipal centers at low cost, including agricultural operators. Efforts to date include a presentation of the initial results on the development of a regional wastewater reuse decision support model, a graduate research, and a submitted manuscript. Importantly, graduate student training has been a significant part of this project. Changes/Problems:
Nothing Reported
What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project's main focus in this area has been on the training and professional development of two PhD students. In the US, Schwabe and Jassby are training a PhD student (Quyhn Tran) in Environmental and Chemical Engineering through one-on-one mentoring. In Israel, Kan and Chefetz are training Ami Reznik in Environmental Economics and Management. Each has played an integral role in developing the their respective models with Tran developing the RWRM model in the US and Reznik developing the first version of the RWRM. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?As this is the first year of a two year project, we've been focused on developing and testing the models. But we have disseminated the results from the decision support model at three conferences (see "Products") and have submitted a manuscript to the journal, Environmental Science and Technology. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?For the next reporting period, which will be for the second and final year of the project, we will bring the two join the two major elements of the project -- the wastewater reuse models from both countries with the crop model. This will require significant coordinated efforts across the two teams - the US team and the Israeli team. Once this is accomplished, we will then submit manuscripts, give presentations at the local, regional, national, and international levels to the academic and water community on our findings and results. Finally, given this is a two-year seed grant, we will then develop a more indepth longer term study to further develop and calibrate the model for flexible application to water systems nationally and internationlly.
Impacts What was accomplished under these goals?
To date, the US team has developed the cost and TWW output functions that relate effluent characteristics (quantity and quality) and cost to influent characteristics (quantity and quality), wastewater treatment technology, and input prices. These cost and wastewater treatment output functions will be developed for technologies that are currently being used as well as emerging technologies. Such functions are necessary components to the overall RWRM and can, if need be, stand along functions that may be of interest to water agencies as they consider the feasibility and costs of adopting different wastewater treatment technologies. Both teams are working on generating the state-of-the-art response functions that relate crop yield, quality, and safety to the use of TWW based on best available science, and past and ongoing experiments. Finally, the Israeli team developed a first version of the RWRM based on the case of Israel. This is a dynamic discrete-time non-linear mathematical programming model that searches for optimal water allocation and infrastructural investments along time and space, while taking into account a range of economic data, physical factors and constraints. The model incorporates TWW as a source of water for agricultural production, which in turn releases freshwater for the needs of the domestic consumers, which grow due to population growth. Yet, the quality of water in general, and that of TWW in particular, is out of the scope of the model, and will be incorporated later in the project.We developed a first version of the RWRM based on the case of Israel. This is a dynamic discrete-time non-linear mathematical programming model that searches for optimal water allocation and infrastructural investments along time and space, while taking into account a range of economic data, physical factors and constraints. The model incorporates TWW as a source of water for agricultural production, which in turn releases freshwater for the needs of the domestic consumers, which grow due to population growth. Yet, the quality of water in general, and that of TWW in particular, is out of the scope of the model, and will be incorporated during the next year through the integration with the model developed by the US team.
Publications
- Type:
Journal Articles
Status:
Submitted
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
Tran, Quynh; Schwabe, Kurt; Jassby, David. Wastewater Reuse for Agriculture: A Development of a Regional Water Reuse Decision-Support Model (RWRM) for Cost-Effective Irrigation Sources. Submitted to Environmental Science and Technology (April 28th, 2016). 34 manuscript pages.
- Type:
Conference Papers and Presentations
Status:
Other
Year Published:
2015
Citation:
Tran, Q., Schwabe, K., and D. Jassby. 2015. Wastewater Reuse of Agriculture. Presentation at the Towards Food, Energy and Water (FEW) Security in California under Changing Conditions: the Nexus perspective. UCLA, Los Angeles, CA., December 3, 2015
- Type:
Conference Papers and Presentations
Status:
Other
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
Tran, Q., K. Schwabe, and D. Jassby. 2016. Wastewater Reuse: A Study of Wastewater Treatment Technologies and Their Impacts on Wastewater Effluents for Agriculture. Presented at the 251st ACS National Meeting & Exposition. San Diego, CA., March 14-17, 2016.
- Type:
Conference Papers and Presentations
Status:
Published
Year Published:
2016
Citation:
Reznik, A., E. Feinerman, I. Finkelshtain, F. Fisher, A. Huber-Lee, B. Joyce and I. Kan. 2016. Economic Implications of Agricultural Reuse of Treated Wastewater in Israel: A Statewide Long-Term Perspective. Presented at an International Symposium on the The Economic Integration of Agriculture in Israel and Palestine.
Rehovot, Israel, 5-6 April 2016
|
|