Source: UNIVERSITY OF NEVADA submitted to
USING HALOPHYTIC PLANTS TO IMPROVE FOOD SECURITY AND ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY IN DRYLAND ECOSYSTEMS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
REVISED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1006332
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
NEV05294
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2015
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2019
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Verburg, PA, .
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF NEVADA
(N/A)
RENO,NV 89557
Performing Department
Natural Resources & Environmental Sciences
Non Technical Summary
Irrigated agriculture provides almost half of world food production, but about 20% of irrigated lands are undergoing salinization, which results in reduced or complete loss of crop yields.We will investigate the potential for plants that prefer to grow in salty soils or waters (i.e., halophytes) to produce food for human or livestock consumption, produce biofuel for bioenergy production, and to reduce salt content of soil or nearby water bodies. Specific project objectives are to: 1) characterize growth, yield, and salt uptake rates for halophytic crops; 2) characterize halophytic crop nutritional levels and biofuel potential; 3) examine impacts of halophytic crops on soil and water quality; and 4) model halophytic crop production and salt removal. The intellectual merit of the proposed work is the development of a model that can characterize plant-water-soil salt dynamics to enable assessment of the potential of using halophytes to increase food production or to improve soil and water quality. Such a model does not currently exist. Should this approach prove useful, broader impacts include enhancing food security and benefitting the Nevada and US economy. In addition, the modeling approach developed can be used in other locations in the US and the world. This project directly addresses the research priority of the Nevada Agricultural Experiment Station of air, land and water degradation because of its emphasis on addressing the management of soil and water salinity. The proposal also addresses animal/human nutrition and health because it examines the value of these salt-loving crops to animals and humans. Finally, the project directly addresses the cross-cutting theme of food production by examining the ability of using halophytic crops to improve productivity of agricultural lands.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
40%
Applied
50%
Developmental
10%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1030199206130%
1020199106040%
1020199208030%
Goals / Objectives
The proposed project's long-term goal is to enhance food security and environmental quality by increasing agricultural production on marginalized saline croplands through the use of halophytic crops. For the purposes of this proposal, we define "marginal lands" as those that have limited options for maintaining or increasing crop production due to soil salinity constraints (CGIAR 1999).
Project Methods
We will investigate these hypotheses through the following tasks:1. Select field plots at Main Station Field lab: Following a preliminary soil survey (see Task 3), we will select field plot locations and construct an irrigation system to them on non-saline and salt-affected lands on the Main Station Farm.2. Planting of halophytic plants at field sites: Four halophytes will be planted: 1) a perennial shrub, Rubber rabbitbrush (Chrysothamnus nauseosus (Pallas) Britt., 2) a perennial grass, AC Saltlander green wheatgrass (Pseudoroegneria spicata x Elytrigia repens), 3) a perennial forb, curlycup gumweed (Grindelia squarrosa (pursh) Dunal), and 4) an annual forb, glasswort (Salicornia europaea). These halophytes represent potential sources of biofuel (rabbitbrush, gumweed), quality livestock forage (AC Saltlander green wheatgrass), and a vegetable product for livestock forage source and direct human consumption (glasswort).The experimental design for the field trials includes halophytes planted with the following treatments:Non-saline soil with irrigation at 100% of evapotranspiration (ET)Saline soil with irrigation at 100% of ET plus appropriate leaching required to leach salts below rooting depth prior to the growing seasonSaline soil with irrigation at 100% of ET with no leachingSaline soil with irrigation at 75% of ET with no leachingSaline soil with irrigation at 50% of ET with no leachingThe ET amount considered 100% of ET will be the real-time reference ET obtained from the Main Station Field lab's on-site weather station. The experimental design will be a randomized complete block with 4 replications. The seeded species will be whole experiments and the irrigation levels will be sub-plots.3. Sampling and analysis of plants, soil, and water for salt ions and nutrient content:a. Soil sampling and analysis: We will assess effects of halophytes on salt accumulation by measuring soil and soil solution chemistry throughout the project. At project start, bulk density and soil texture will be measured for each subplot. Soil salt profiles will be determined at the start and end of the project while soil solution chemistry will be monitored on a monthly basis depending on soil moisture conditions. In addition, previous work indicated the APEX model was sensitive to soil organic carbon content and soil albedo, both of which will be measured at the start and end of the study in each plot.b. Plant sampling and analysis: At completion of the first growing season, perennial plant species (rabbitbrush, AC Saltlander green wheatgrass, curlycup gumweed) will be sampled to determine initial establishment and survival by irrigation treatment. The evaluation will consist of determining plant density and height along the seeded rows. The annual herb (glasswort) will be harvested and weighed to determine biomass production by irrigation treatment. During the remaining years of the project all plant species will be harvested annually, with biomass determined for each species and irrigation treatment. Harvested plants will be analyzed for the fraction of phosphorus and fraction of water in the crop yield. A subset of plants will be sampled monthly to measure parameters for modeling including leaf area index, maximum root depth, above and below-ground biomass, and crop height.4. In vitro digestibility experiments to assess nutrient availability of halophytes for ruminant animals: Digestibility experiments will be performed on harvested halophytes. The dual-flow continuous culture system is an in vitro technique developed by Hoover et al. (1976) that simulates rumen digestion in which different feeds and artificial saliva are mixed with fresh rumen fluid. In the modern version of this system (Soder et al. 2013), temperature, anaerobiosis, and flow rates are tightly controlled. This technique has been widely used to evaluate the effect of complete diets and individual feed ingredients on ruminal digestion, fermentation, microbial protein synthesis, and nutrient flow (Hristov et al. 2012). Advantages of this technique are: 1) ability to test a large number of treatments 2) ability to test high levels of one specific ingredient, 3) reduced experimental time, 4) reduced amount of total feed used, 5) less animal use, and 6) lower cost when compared to in vivo experiments.5. Assessment of halophyte biofuel potential: Plants will be examined for biofuel potential. Extraction methods of two of the plants, curlycup gumweed and rabbitbrush, are well-developed and comparison of production of biofuels from these two plants on saline soils will be very straight forward. For AC Saltlander green wheatgrass, we will utilize standard extraction methods for determining the biofuel production, following milling to 1/8" size in our hammer mill.6. Enhancement of salinity module for public-domain APEX model: Previous work implemented a preliminary salinity module for the APEX model that has algorithms for salt uptake by plants and salt movement through the plants, water and soil (DeRuyter 2014). We will parameterize and calibrate the model using data from the field and laboratory tasks. In Year 4, we will model management scenarios based on input from Extension workshops (see Task 8) to simulate halophytic plant growth and production on lands with varying levels of salinity to estimate potential biomass and biofuel production, salt extraction from soils, and impacts on salt inputs to surface and shallow groundwater to provide a basis to examine the feasibility of halophytes in Nevada's agricultural production systems.7. Outreach to Pyramid Lake Jr/Sr High School: We will recruit students from Pyramid Lake Junior/Senior High School to work for one to two weeks each summer with the project to encourage these students to consider careers in the sciences. We will work with the science teacher at Pyramid Lake Junior/Senior High School to recruit students for this task.8. Involvement of Cooperative Extension: Extension activities for this project consist of several objectives. Extension Objective 1 will begin at project initiation to integrate all research activities with a robust extension educational program aimed at developing a well-trained cadre of professional and lay audiences possessing the skills and knowledge to select and grow appropriate halophytic crops to increase food production on saline soils in dryland ecosystems. These audiences include agricultural producers, production professionals employed by State and Federal agencies, and consultants, and appropriate industry representatives and organizations. Extension Objective 2 involves development and dissemination of extension educational products concerning species selection, required cultural techniques, profit potential and potential production risks. During Year 1, the field research site described in Task 1 will also be established as a field demonstration site as part of Extension Objective 3. This site will demonstrate the economic potential of halophytic species, cultural techniques favoring profitable production, and changes in soil salinity over time. Field-based workshops, tours, small group consultations and intensive on-farm sessions with interested producers will be used in conjunction with the educational products of Extension Objective 2 to develop the skilled cadre of practitioners desired in Extension Objective 1. We will assist early adopters from the Nevada agricultural producer community in establishing off-site demonstration plots on their farms to expand the project's scope and credence with neighboring producers who may be interested in implementing project results, but require more evidence of success before committing to recommended techniques. Extension Objective 4 is to evaluate the project using a variety of techniques applied over the life of the project. Project evaluation will include short-, medium- and long-term evaluations of project success in achieving project goals.

Progress 10/01/16 to 09/30/17

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audiences reached by our efforts during this reporting period include the scientific community (through presentations at professional meetings), the general public (through field demonstration days), farmers and land managers (through presentations at regional meetings). Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project provided employment for several undergraduate and graduate students. Students presented results from their work at statewide and international conferences. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The project was presented at the CABNR Field Day in the Fall of 2017 and students and lead investigators gave presentations at regional and international meetings. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will continue to experiment with different quinoa varieities as results with quinoa have shown promise. • Dr. Felipe Barrios-Macias has become involved with the project after one of the co-PIs retired. Dr. Barrios-Macias is currently involved in testing different quinoa cultivars to determine which cultivars may be best adapted to Nevada climate conditions. This work will continue during the next reporting period. • We will continue to collaborate with the UNR faculty in the department of Geological Sciences who are interested in remote monitoring of both plant productivity and soil salinity using hyperspectral imaging. The first season of using drones and assoicated remote monitoring platforms has shown promise and this work will continue during the 2018 field season.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Impacts Preliminary results from our field study show that quinoa, amaranth, and green wheatgrass have a high potential to perform well in Nevada. However, weed control remains an issue given that the main weed, pigweed, belongs to the same family as quinoa and amaranth making use of herbicide almost impossible. However, leaves of pigweed can be used for human consumption and may also take up significant amounts of salt thereby potentially helping remediate salt-affected soils. We made modifications to the APEX model, allowing the model to explicitly simulate halophytic crops and salt balances in plant-soil systems. Data from the field and greenhouse studies were used to parameterize and test the model. The modifications made to the model will allow scientists and land users to assess the potential for growing halophytic crops in salt-affected soils in a wide range of environments. Local farmers have expressed great interest in being able to grow quinoa and other salt-tolerant crops. If this project is successful, it could potentially have a major impact for agriculture in Nevada as soil salinity is an increasingly large problem particularly as drought conditions have affected many agricultural regions in Nevada. Activities During the spring of 2017, salt was added to soils to increase salinity levels in some plots, fields were seeded and the field study commenced as planned. Since last year we did not have good results with rubber rabbitbrush and gumweed we decided not to seed these species. Instead, we added two amaranth varieties that previously have shown promise in Nevada. We also adjusted the plot layout to have a more balanced experimental design allowing for proper statistical analysis. Prior to seeding, soils were sampled in control and saline plots down to a depth of 40 cm. We installed additional soil sensors at 10 and 40 cm depth in control and saline plots to measure soil temperature, soil moisture and soil salinity every hour. The previous year we only had six measurement locations but we added additional stations to have a total of 20 locations. Surface soil salinity was measured biweekly in each plot. All species emerged but emergence was typically delayed in the saline plots. Given the irrigation issues from the previous year we decided not to implement the different watering regimes as initially proposed. This year we were able to level the field much better than last year and as a result, distribution of irrigation water was much more even than the previous year. At the end of the growing season, all crops were harvested and samples were analyzed for biomass production. Vegetation samples are currently being dried and prepared for analysis of salt content. While quinoa biomass production was relatively high in both control and saline plots, the plants produced very few seeds presumably due to high summer temperatures experienced in Nevada. After the harvest, soil cores were taken in control and saline soils to a depth of 40 cm and samples are currently drying prior to analysis. Similar to last year we had issues with weeds. Especially pigweed was prominent in quinoa and amaranth plots suppressing crop growth. Data from a greenhouse study have been collected and analyzed. Some of the results have been presented at conferences (see below) and we are currently working on a paper describing the results of this study. The modeling efforts are ongoing and APEX has been parametrized using greenhouse and field data. Given that quinoa showed the best emergence and biomass production, our modeling efforts are focusing on quinoa. We added routines to the model that allow for simulating specific responses of the vegetation to soil salinity. In addition, the model explicitly simulates salt uptake by the vegetation and tacks the amount of salt present in the soil. A paper describing the modifications to the model is currently being prepared. Given the large amount of work involved in monitoring biomass in the field during the growing season we reached out to faculty at UNR involved with Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS) research. This year we used a UAS-based platform to remotely monitor biomass production during the growing season. The data from the remote monitoring is currently being analyzed. In addition, we are currently assessing the feasibility to use remote platforms to measure soil salinity. An initial study is being conducted in the laboratory with field measurements planned for 2018.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2016 Citation: Goehring, N.; Saito, L.; Verburg, P.; Jeong, J.; Garrett, A. Modeling salt movement and halophytic crop growth on marginal lands with the APEX model. AGU Fall meeting December 2016
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2016 Citation: Garrett, A.; Stracke, S.; Nowak, B.; Goehring, N.; Saito, L.; Verburg, P. Assessment of Halophyte Growth in Saline Environments. AGU Fall meeting December 2016
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Goehring, N.; Saito, L.; Verburg, P.; Jeong, J.; Garrett, A. Modeling salt movement and halophytic crop growth on marginal lands with the APEX model. NWRA Annual Meeting February 2017
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Garrett, A.; Stracke, S.; Nowak, B.; Goehring, N.; Saito, L.; Verburg, P. Assessment of Salinity Impacts on Halophyte Growth. NWRA Annual Meeting February 2017
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Verburg P, Soil Salinity in Nevada: Cause, Solutions and Opportunities Invited talk. NWRA Annual Meeting February 2017
  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2017 Citation: Verburg P, Food security in Nevada; Challenges, Solutions and Opportunities. Invited talk. Economic Development Conference, Las Vegas, September 2017.


Progress 10/01/15 to 09/30/16

Outputs
Target Audience:Should halophytes prove to be viable for reducing salts on lands or having economic value, land managers and farmers in the Great Basin with salt-affected lands will be able to use the research to use halophytes to maintain or restore their lands to get improved economic value from degraded lands. Changes/Problems: Our experiences from the field season show that Quinoa has a high potential to grow in Nevada. Other crops used in this trial. particularly Rubber Rabbitbrush and Gumweed appear to be more problematic even though they should be adapted to saline conditions. Based on our field season we propose to modify the setup of our second field season by focusing on Quinoa and AC Saltlander. Ability to level fields will determine how successful the next growing season will be. We will look at possibilities to get access to a laser-leveling system to ensure even water applications. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?An undergraduate student has received a complementary general undergraduate research award (GURA) and is performing a greenhouse experiment with two of the halophytic plant species. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?First results from the project were presented at the Nevada Experiment Station Field Day at the Main Station Field Lab on September 27, 2016. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Given the low emergence of rabbitbrush and gumweed we propose to concentrate our efforts on Quinoa potentially using different varieties and irrigation regimes. Emergence of weeds was an issue in several plots. Given that some of the weeds belong to the same family as Quinoa, no herbicide is available that can be safely used without it affecting Quinoa. During the fall of 2016 we will treat the fields with an herbicide to prevent emergence during the spring. In addition, we propose to conduct trials with herbicides to determine if certain herbicides can be used without affecting Quinoa. Dr. Felipe Barrios-Macias has become involved with the project since co-PI Bob Nowak will be retiring the end of December. Dr. Barrios-Macias has experience with Quinoa and has ongoing collaborations with other universities conducting research on Quinoa. We will attempt to obtain seeds from other cultivars to determine which cultivars may be best adapted for growth in Nevada. We will collaborating with the UNR faculty in the Geology department who are interested in remote monitoring of both plant productivity and soil salinity using hyperspectral imaging. We have obtained all the necessary FAA permits to commence flights using drones and assoicated remote monitoring platforms.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? During the fall of 2015 and spring of 2016 sprinkler systems were installed at Main Station Farm, salt was added to soils to increase salinity levels in some plots, fields were seeded and the field study commenced as planned. We seeded Rainbow Quinoa, AC Saltlander Green Wheatgrass, rubber rabbitbrush, and gumweed. Prior to seeding, soils were sampled in control and saline plots down to a depth of 120 cm. We installed soil sensors at 10 and 40 cm depth in control and saline plots to measure soil temperature, soil moisture and soil salinity every hour. The emergence of Quinoa and AC Saltlander was pronounced but emergence of rabbitbrush and gumweed was minimal. Quinoa and AC Saltlander emergence and growth was variable however which may have been related to uneven irrigation. We were not able to level the field due to absence of a laser-leveling system causing soil moisture to be variable. Given the irrigation issues we decided not to implement the different watering regimes as initially proposed. In addition, presence of weeds may have contributed to uneven emergence and biomass production. Quinoa was sampled throughout the study to estimate biomass in support of the APEX modeling efforts. In addition, surface soil salinity was measured biweekly in each plot. At the end of the growing season, Quinoa and AC Saltlander was harvested and samples were analyzed for biomass production and salt content and results are currently being analyzed. While Quinoa biomass production was relatively high in both control and saline plots, the plants produced very few seeds for reasons that were unclear. After the harvest, soil cores were taken in control and saline soils to a depth of 120 cm. We conducted a greenhouse study assessing the effects of soil and irrigation salinity on Quinoa and AC Saltlander biomass production and salt uptake. Processing of the soil and plant samples is still ongoing and samples will be sent off for analysis to measure salt content. These data will be used for calibration of the APEX model. In general, the study showed that both biomass and salt uptake increased with increasing salinity level. The modeling efforts are ongoing and APEX has been parametrized using greenhouse and field data. One of the key components of the model that needs to be incorporated is how salts are taken up by the vegetation. Currently, different routines are being tested incorporating both active and passive salt uptake. Given that Quinoa showed the best emergence and biomass production, our modeling efforts are focusing on Quinoa. During the summer, a group of high school student from the Pyramid Paiute tribe was involved conducting sampling in the project. We also had one REU student involved in the project assisting with both greenhouse and field experiments. Given the large amount of work involved in monitoring biomass in the field during the growing season we have reached out to faculty involved with UAS research. We will use UAS-based platforms to remotely monitor biomass production during the growing season of 2017. In addition, we will assess the feasibility to use remote platforms to measure soil salinity.

Publications


    Progress 07/01/15 to 09/30/15

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Should halophytes prove to be viable for reducing salts on lands or having economic value, land managers and farmers in the Great Basin with salt-affected lands will be able to use the research to use halophytes to maintain or restore their lands to get improved economic value from degraded lands. Changes/Problems:An undergraduate student received a complementary general undergraduate research award (GURA) and is performing a greenhouse experiment with two of the halophytic plant species. Soils at Main Station Farm were not very saline so we are planning to add salt to the soil for the field plots. Only one graduate student was hired on the project in Fall 2015, but additional undergraduate students have been helping with the project. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?An undergraduate student has received a complementary general undergraduate research award (GURA) and is performing a greenhouse experiment with two of the halophytic plant species. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Project goals and plans were presented to the public at the Nevada Field Day at the Valley Road Field Lab on September 26, 2015. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The field sites should be planted with four halophytic plant species and monitored for soil and water quality and plant characteristics such as biomass, leaf area index, etc. A graduate student will visit Temple, TX to work with APEX model developers to set up models for the greenhouse experiments and the field sites. A graduate student will present about salinity models at the Nevada Water Resources Association Conference in Las Vegas. Bob Nowak, Antonio Faciola, and Michael Rosen will travel to Uzbekistan to visit related projects with Dr. Kristina Toderich of the International Center for Biosaline Agriculture. Antonio Faciola and his lab will analyze forage samples collected in Uzbekistan for nutritional value.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? We determined where to place field plots at the Main Station Farm and have begun preparations for treating the fields for weeds. Modifications to irrigation at Main Station Farm were made to enable irrigation of the field plots.

    Publications

    • Type: Websites Status: Published Year Published: 2015 Citation: http://www.ag.unr.edu/saito/research/naes_salt.aspx